Texas Case Summaries
Federal Enforcement »

Mogollon v. Bank of New York Mellon — Court lets Stanford Ponzi scheme aiding-and-abetting claims proceed

Unreported / Non-Citable

Case
Sergio Mogollon and Colleen Lowe v. Bank of New York Mellon
Court
U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Texas
Judge
David C. Godbey, Chief United States District Judge
Date Decided
August 9, 2023
Docket No.
3:19-cv-03070-N
Topics
Personal Jurisdiction; Venue; Aiding and Abetting; Ponzi Schemes

Background

Sergio Mogollon and Colleen Lowe, seeking to represent a class of investors who purchased fraudulent certificates of deposit issued by Stanford International Bank, sued Bank of New York Mellon in the District of New Jersey. They alleged that BNYM aided and abetted R. Allen Stanford’s Ponzi scheme by recruiting financial advisers, enhancing Stanford’s reputation, helping transfer funds, and soliciting Stanford’s business, including through activities connected to its subsidiary Pershing LLC.

The Judicial Panel on Multidistrict Litigation transferred the case to the Northern District of Texas. That court initially dismissed the action under New Jersey’s statute of limitations, but the Fifth Circuit reversed. On remand, the district court addressed BNYM’s remaining arguments that New Jersey lacked personal jurisdiction, venue there was improper, and the amended complaint failed to state claims for aiding and abetting fraud and breach of fiduciary duty.

The Court’s Holding

The court denied BNYM’s motion to dismiss. It held that the District of New Jersey could exercise specific personal jurisdiction because BNYM allegedly attended meetings with Stanford in New Jersey and directed due-diligence communications, marketing materials, emails, and conference calls into the state. Those contacts were sufficiently related to plaintiffs’ allegations that BNYM helped recruit for Stanford, enhanced Stanford’s reputation, assisted fund transfers, and solicited its business.

The court also held that venue was proper in New Jersey because BNYM was subject to personal jurisdiction there. Applying New Jersey law to the substantive claims, the court found plausible allegations of substantial assistance and scienter. The alleged recruiting, reputational support, and fund-transfer assistance could constitute substantial assistance, while warning signs—including Stanford’s lack of transparency, unsupported high returns, an SEC investigation, and concerns raised by named BNYM employees—supported a reasonable inference that BNYM knew it was assisting fraud and breach of fiduciary duty.

Key Takeaways

  • In-person meetings and communications directed into New Jersey supplied sufficient forum contacts for specific personal jurisdiction at the pleading stage.
  • BNYM’s alleged recruiting, reputational enhancement, and assistance transferring funds collectively supported a plausible inference of substantial assistance to Stanford’s scheme.
  • Allegations of multiple fraud indicators and concerns raised internally by identified BNYM employees were sufficient to plead scienter.

Why It Matters

The ruling allows the proposed investor class’s aiding-and-abetting claims to proceed beyond the motion-to-dismiss stage; it does not determine that BNYM is liable. It also illustrates how a financial institution’s forum-directed relationship-building activities and alleged awareness of warning signs can support jurisdiction and plausible aiding-and-abetting claims.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top