Texas Case Summaries
Federal Enforcement »

AuthWallet v. Amarillo National Bank — Magistrate judge recommends dismissal of remaining claims

Reported / Citable

Case
AuthWallet, LLC v. Amarillo National Bank
Court
U.S. District Court for the Western District of Texas, Midland/Odessa Division
Judge
DEREK T. GILLILAND
Date Decided
July 29, 2026
Docket No.
7:24-cv-00064-DC-DTG
Topics
Patent litigation; Counterclaims; Third-party practice; Substitution after death

Background

AuthWallet sued Amarillo National Bank for alleged infringement of U.S. Patent No. 8,099,368. The district court dismissed AuthWallet’s complaint without prejudice on February 28, 2025, and gave AuthWallet 14 days to refile. AuthWallet did not file a new complaint.

After that dismissal, the bank filed a counterclaim and third-party complaint involving Todd Russell Coulter, who had asserted ownership of the patent. Coulter filed claims against both AuthWallet and the bank, and AuthWallet asserted a counterclaim seeking a declaration that it owned the patent. Coulter later died; after service of a suggestion of death on his successors, no one moved to substitute for him.

The Court’s Holding

Magistrate Judge Derek T. Gilliland recommended that the district court strike the bank’s counterclaim as untimely. The bank filed it without leave more than 200 days after its original response deadline and after the underlying complaint had been dismissed. The magistrate judge concluded that a counterclaim presupposes an existing claim against the party asserting it.

The magistrate judge further recommended dismissing without prejudice the bank’s third-party complaint against Coulter because Rule 14 did not permit impleader once AuthWallet’s original claims had been dismissed. He also recommended dismissing without prejudice Coulter’s claims and AuthWallet’s counterclaim against Coulter under Rule 25(a)(1), because no substitution motion was filed within 90 days after service on Coulter’s successors. All pending motions should be denied as moot, the report recommended.

Key Takeaways

  • A defendant generally cannot file a counterclaim after the plaintiff’s operative claims have been dismissed, absent proper leave and a live claim to answer.
  • Rule 14 third-party practice requires potential derivative liability on the plaintiff’s original claim.
  • Claims involving a deceased party are subject to dismissal without prejudice when no timely substitution is made after proper service of a suggestion of death.

Why It Matters

The report underscores that post-dismissal litigation filings must fit within the Federal Rules’ pleading and impleader framework. A party seeking affirmative relief after dismissal may need a procedurally proper new action rather than a counterclaim or third-party complaint in the closed merits dispute.

Because this is a report and recommendation, its proposed dispositions remained subject to review by the district judge and to timely objections.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top