Texas Case Summaries
Federal Enforcement »

Wells v. Bisignano — Fifth Circuit affirms dismissal of disability claim for failure to exhaust administrative remedies

Unreported / Non-Citable

Case
Kelvin Wells v. Frank Bisignano, Commissioner of Social Security Administration
Court
U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit
Judge
Willett; Duncan
Date Decided
July 20, 2026
Docket No.
25-30680
Topics
Administrative Law, Social Security, Exhaustion of Remedies, Judicial Review

Background

In January 2023, Kelvin Wells applied for disability-insurance benefits under Title II of the Social Security Act. His initial application was denied by the Social Security Administration’s (SSA) Field Office. Wells then requested a hearing before an administrative law judge (ALJ), who subsequently concluded that Wells was uninsured when his claimed disability began.

Wells appealed the ALJ’s decision to the SSA’s Appeals Council. The Appeals Council vacated the ALJ’s decision and remanded the case, citing conflicting evidence regarding the onset date of Wells’s alleged disability. The Council instructed the ALJ to remand the claim to the Field Office for further evidentiary development and an initial disability determination.

The ALJ followed the Appeals Council’s instruction, remanding Wells’s claim to the Field Office and denying Wells’s request for a new hearing. Wells appealed this denial, but the Appeals Council declined to review it. Wells then sought judicial review of the denial in the U.S. District Court for the Middle District of Louisiana, which dismissed his claim without prejudice under Rule 12(b)(1) for failure to exhaust administrative remedies. Wells subsequently appealed the district court’s dismissal to the Fifth Circuit.

The Court’s Holding

The Fifth Circuit reviewed the district court’s dismissal de novo, noting that it could affirm “on any basis supported by the record.” The court explained that the Social Security Act allows for judicial review in federal court only of “final decision[s],” and that a decision becomes final after a claimant has exhausted four administrative steps: an initial eligibility determination, reconsideration, a hearing before an ALJ, and review by the SSA Appeals Council.

The court agreed with the government’s argument that Wells had not exhausted his administrative remedies. It found that, because the ALJ had remanded the claim to the Field Office as instructed by the Appeals Council, Wells’s claim was still pending an initial determination regarding his disabled status. Therefore, no “final decision” had been rendered by the SSA that would permit federal court review. The court also found no “extraordinary circumstance” articulated by Wells to excuse his failure to exhaust his claim.

Consequently, the Fifth Circuit affirmed the district court’s dismissal. In a clarifying footnote, the court added that while the district court dismissed the claim under Rule 12(b)(1) for lack of subject-matter jurisdiction, exhaustion under § 405(g) of the Social Security Act is nonjurisdictional. Thus, the proper basis for dismissal should have been Rule 12(b)(6) for failure to state a claim upon which relief can be granted, which the Fifth Circuit adopted as an alternative basis for affirming the dismissal.

Key Takeaways

  • Judicial review of Social Security disability claims in federal court is contingent upon a “final decision” from the SSA, which requires full exhaustion of administrative remedies.
  • The administrative exhaustion process involves an initial determination, reconsideration, an ALJ hearing, and review by the Appeals Council.
  • A remand by the Appeals Council to the Field Office for further factfinding means the administrative process is incomplete, and therefore, no “final decision” suitable for judicial review exists.
  • In the Fifth Circuit, failure to exhaust administrative remedies in Social Security cases is considered a nonjurisdictional defect, leading to dismissal under Rule 12(b)(6) for failure to state a claim, rather than Rule 12(b)(1) for lack of subject-matter jurisdiction.

Why It Matters

This ruling provides important clarification for Social Security disability claimants and their attorneys regarding the prerequisites for federal court intervention. It reiterates that claimants must navigate the entirety of the SSA’s multi-step administrative appeals process, including any remands for further development, before a federal court will entertain their claim. The court’s emphasis on the absence of “extraordinary circumstances” for waiving exhaustion highlights the strict application of this requirement.

Furthermore, the Fifth Circuit’s clarification on the appropriate legal basis for dismissal—Rule 12(b)(6) instead of Rule 12(b)(1)—is significant. While the outcome (dismissal) remains the same, this distinction can have implications for future procedural matters, such as whether a subsequent claim can be refiled without prejudice, or the preclusive effect of the dismissal. It aligns the Fifth Circuit with other circuits that treat § 405(g) exhaustion as a nonjurisdictional, waivable prerequisite to suit.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top