Unreported / Non-Citable
Background
In May 1987, parents Jasper Duncan Cartwright and Robbie Williams Cartwright established an irrevocable trust naming their three sons—Russell, Morgan Gentry, and Joe Shannon—as co-trustees and equal beneficiaries. The trust agreement contained language stating that “Grantors have transferred and delivered the property described in the attached exhibit” but the exhibit itself was never located after the parents’ deaths (Robbie in 2003, Duncan in 2019).
When Duncan died in November 2019, a life insurance policy paid $300,000 to the trust, which Russell deposited into a bank account without informing his brothers. The brothers disputed the trust’s assets: Russell claimed the exhibit contained references to a $300,000 insurance policy and two tracts of real property (207 acres and 33.55 acres); Gentry and Joe argued the trust contained only the insurance proceeds and that the real property passed under Duncan’s will, which named only them as beneficiaries.
Gentry and Joe sued Russell for breach of fiduciary duty and sought a declaratory judgment that Russell had no ownership interest in the disputed property. Russell counterclaimed for a declaration that both real property tracts were trust assets. The trial court granted partial summary judgment dismissing some claims but allowed a jury trial on whether the lost exhibit conveyed the property to the trust.
The Court’s Holding
The appellate court affirmed the trial judgment in all respects. On the critical evidentiary issue, the court held that the trial judge did not abuse discretion in admitting Russell’s testimony about the contents of the lost exhibit. Under Texas Rule of Evidence 1004(a), when an original document is lost or destroyed, other evidence of its contents is admissible unless the proponent destroyed it in bad faith. The court found Russell established a sufficient predicate by testifying that he searched his files, computers, home office, and safe after his father’s death in August 2022 but could not find the exhibit.
The jury found by clear and convincing evidence that (1) the exhibit was lost, (2) the lost exhibit conveyed the disputed property to the trust, and (3) Russell conducted himself in good faith as trustee. Although the jury found that Gentry and Joe failed their trustee duties by not distributing Russell’s share of the property and did so in bad faith, the trial court set aside the bad faith findings through a judgment notwithstanding the verdict. The final judgment declared that Russell, Gentry, and Joe each own an undivided one-third interest in all trust assets, including the $300,000 insurance proceeds and both tracts of real property.
Key Takeaways
- Lost Document Evidence: Testimony about the contents of a lost document is admissible under Texas Rule of Evidence 1004 if the witness establishes a proper predicate showing loss through search and inability to locate it, without bad faith destruction.
- Fiduciary Duties Among Co-Trustees: Co-trustees owe each other duties of good faith and must act in accordance with the trust’s purposes; failure to distribute a beneficiary’s share may constitute breach, though bad faith must be proven separately.
- Trust Intent Controls: When trust language explicitly references an attached exhibit describing transferred property, courts may rely on witness testimony to establish what the exhibit contained, particularly when the witness had direct knowledge and conducted a thorough search.
- Attorney’s Fees Denial Upheld: The court affirmed the trial court’s discretion to deny attorney’s fees even when a party prevails in trust disputes, based on language in the trust agreement.
Why It Matters
This decision provides important guidance on the admissibility of evidence concerning lost trust documents. Texas courts have long permitted extrinsic evidence of a document’s contents when it is lost, but this case clarifies that the predicate requirement does not mandate an exhaustive formalized procedure—only that the witness testify credibly about searching for the document in logical places and failing to locate it. For estate planning purposes, the ruling underscores the critical importance of maintaining executed exhibits to trust agreements, as their loss creates significant litigation risk and may lead to disputes about the trust’s actual assets and the parties’ intentions.
The court’s affirmance also reinforces that co-trustees are not automatically absolved from fiduciary duties simply because a document is missing. Russell’s good faith search and his role as the brother who attended the attorney’s meeting in 1987 and witnessed the document’s creation were material to the jury’s verdict. Practitioners should note that even when courts allow testimony about lost documents, the outcome depends heavily on witness credibility and the circumstances surrounding both the document’s creation and its loss.