Reported / Citable
Background
Tiffany Michelle Carter filed suit against Allstate Fire and Casualty Insurance Company and other defendants, including Mariah Newsome, in what appears to be a state court action. The case was removed to federal court based on federal question or diversity jurisdiction. Carter filed a motion to remand the case back to state court, arguing the removal was improper. The case was referred to Magistrate Judge Peter Bray for all pretrial purposes in November 2025.
Judge Bray issued a Memorandum and Recommendation on May 15, 2026, recommending that the motion to remand be denied and that plaintiff’s claims against defendant Mariah Newsome be dismissed without prejudice based on improper joinder. No objections were filed to the magistrate judge’s recommendation, so the district court reviewed it for plain error.
The Court’s Holding
Judge George C. Hanks, Jr. approved and adopted the magistrate judge’s recommendation in its entirety, finding no plain error in the record. The court denied Carter’s motion to remand, keeping the case in federal court. The court dismissed all claims against defendant Mariah Newsome without prejudice on the basis that Newsome was improperly joined as a defendant to the action.
Because Newsome’s claims were already dismissed on improper joinder grounds, the court also denied Newsome’s two motions to dismiss as moot. The dismissal without prejudice means the claims against Newsome are not finally barred, and could potentially be reasserted if proper joinder could be established in the future.
Key Takeaways
- A defendant may be removed from an action if they are improperly joined, even if the plaintiff’s primary claims could not independently support federal jurisdiction.
- Dismissal without prejudice on improper joinder grounds does not prevent a plaintiff from refiling claims against the dismissed defendant in state court or in a properly joined federal action.
- Federal courts will not entertain motions to dismiss when the defendant has already been removed from the action on joinder grounds, rendering such motions moot.
- The removal of a defendant on improper joinder grounds does not automatically remand the remaining claims back to state court.
Why It Matters
This order reinforces the doctrine of improper joinder as a basis for removal jurisdiction. Under longstanding federal practice, a defendant can engineer removal by arguing that a co-defendant was improperly joined solely to destroy diversity jurisdiction. When a court finds improper joinder, it may remove that defendant even if doing so would not otherwise support federal jurisdiction over the remaining claims. This principle allows the removal machinery to be used not just to expand federal jurisdiction, but to eliminate defendants who lack the requisite nexus to the claims.
For plaintiffs, the dismissal without prejudice provides some relief—the claims are not permanently barred. However, for defendants seeking to stay in federal court, improper joinder doctrine presents both a challenge and an opportunity. It challenges plaintiffs’ ability to sue multiple defendants when their claims arise from different sources, but it offers defendants a straightforward argument for removal when properly invoked.