Texas Case Summaries
Federal Enforcement »

Dadi v. Thompson — Court Orders Release of Detained Alien After Finding Prolonged Detention Without Foreseeable Removal Violates Due Process

Reported / Citable

Case
Raymond Dadi v. Warden Bobby Thompson, South Texas Detention Facility (GEO), et al.
Court
U.S. District Court for the Western District of Texas, San Antonio Division
Date Decided
June 12, 2026
Docket No.
5:26-cv-02646-FB
Topics
Habeas Corpus; Immigration Detention; Due Process; Zadvydas Standard; Travel Documents
Source
Read the full opinion

Background

Raymond Dadi entered the United States in 1984 on a visitor visa and later married a U.S. citizen. After his conditional resident status was terminated in 1989, he was ordered removed in absentia. In 1991, he obtained a California delayed-registration birth certificate claiming U.S. citizenship and filed to reopen his removal proceedings, but was convicted of Unlawful Procurement of U.S. Citizenship the same year. Following additional motions and proceedings, an immigration judge ordered Dadi removed to Iran in 1993; the Board of Immigration Appeals affirmed this order in 1997. In 1999, Dadi sought to change the country of removal to Saudi Arabia (with Iran as alternate), and that order became final.

On September 20, 2025, ICE took Dadi into custody at the South Texas Detention Facility in Pearsall, Texas. Over the following seven months, ICE attempted to obtain travel documents for Dadi’s removal to Iran by submitting requests to the Iranian Consulate in November 2025, which were returned for edits and resubmitted in January 2026. However, the Iranian Consulate refused to issue travel documents because Dadi lacks an Iranian passport or birth certificate—documents Iran requires for processing removal requests. ICE conceded it does not possess these documents and has neither located them nor submitted travel document requests to any alternate country, including Saudi Arabia. Additionally, ICE is unaware of any currently scheduled removals to Iran or any other country.

Dadi filed his habeas corpus petition in April 2026, seeking immediate release pending removal, arguing that his prolonged detention without a reasonably foreseeable removal date violates his Fifth Amendment due process rights.

The Court’s Holding

The Magistrate Judge recommended granting Dadi’s habeas corpus petition. The court applied the framework established in Zadvydas v. Davis, 533 U.S. 678 (2001), which limits detention beyond the initial 90-day removal period to a period “reasonably necessary” to effectuate removal. Under Zadvydas, detention for six months is “presumptively reasonable,” but beyond that threshold, if removal is no longer reasonably foreseeable, continued detention violates due process absent special circumstances under 8 C.F.R. § 241.14.

The court found that Dadi established a lack of significant likelihood of removal in the reasonably foreseeable future. Critically, Iran’s refusal to issue travel documents without original identity papers means Dadi’s removal is contingent on obtaining documents he does not possess and that ICE cannot obtain. The court noted that seven months into detention with no progress toward removal, no scheduled removals to Iran, and no requests submitted to alternate countries, Dadi faces “potentially permanent” detention—precisely the scenario Zadvydas prohibits. The government conceded it cannot meet its burden of demonstrating that removal is likely in the reasonably foreseeable future.

Accordingly, the magistrate recommended that Dadi be released from custody under conditions compliant with 8 U.S.C. § 1231(a)(3) and directed the parties to propose post-removal supervision conditions within seven days for the district court’s consideration.

Key Takeaways

  • Detention of aliens awaiting removal cannot continue indefinitely; after six months, if removal is not reasonably foreseeable, continued detention violates due process under Zadvydas.
  • When a removal country requires original identity documents that the alien does not possess and the government cannot obtain, removal may become “potentially permanent,” mandating release.
  • The burden shifts to the government to demonstrate removal is likely when an alien was previously released from custody on supervision; failure to do so requires release.
  • Lack of travel document requests to alternate removal countries, combined with no scheduled removals and prolonged periods without progress, supports a finding that removal is not reasonably foreseeable.

Why It Matters

This decision reinforces the Zadvydas principle that indefinite detention of aliens awaiting removal is unconstitutional. As ICE detention practices face increasing scrutiny, courts are increasingly recognizing that missing identity documents—particularly for countries like Iran with strict documentation requirements—can render removal infeasible and trigger mandatory release. This ruling aligns with recent decisions from federal courts across the country granting habeas relief in similar circumstances involving Iranian nationals lacking required identity documents.

The decision is significant for immigration practitioners and detainees because it establishes that the government cannot maintain custody indefinitely simply by maintaining a valid removal order. Seven months without material progress toward removal, combined with ICE’s concessions that it lacks required documents and has no alternative removal plans, constitutes constitutional violation. The ruling signals that courts will scrutinize the government’s actual efforts to effectuate removal, not merely the legality of the original removal order.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top